-
Audit approach overview
Our audit approach will allow our client's accounting personnel to make the maximum contribution to…
-
Annual and short period audit
At P&A Grant Thornton, we provide annual and short period financial statement audit services that go…
-
Review engagement
A review involves limited investigation with a narrower scope than an audit, and is undertaken…
-
Other Related Services
We make it a point to keep our clients abreast of the developments and updates relating to the…
-
Tax advisory
With our knowledge of tax laws and audit procedures, we help safeguard the substantive and procedural…
-
Tax compliance
We aim to minimize the impact of taxation, enabling you to maximize your potential savings and to…
-
Corporate services
For clients that want to do business in the Philippines, we assist in determining the appropriate and…
-
Tax education and advocacy
Our advocacy work focuses on clarifying the interpretation of laws and regulations, suggesting…
-
Business risk services
Our business risk services cover a wide range of solutions that assist you in identifying, addressing and…
-
Business consulting services
Our business consulting services are aimed at addressing concerns in your operations, processes and…
-
Transaction services
Transaction advisory includes all of our services specifically directed at assisting in investment, mergers…
-
Forensic advisory
Our forensic advisory services include assessing your vulnerability to fraud and identifying fraud risk…
-
Cyber advisory
Our focus is to help you identify and manage the cyber risks you might be facing within your…
-
ProActive Hotline
Providing support in preventing and detecting fraud by creating a safe and secure whistleblowing system…
-
Accounting services
At P&A Grant Thornton, we handle accounting services for several companies from a wide range of…
-
Staff augmentation services
We offer Staff Augmentation services where our staff, under the direction and supervision of the company’s…
-
Payroll Processing
Payroll processing services are provided by P&A Grant Thornton Outsourcing Inc. More and more…
-
Our values
Grant Thornton prides itself on being a values-driven organisation and we have more than 38,500 people in…
-
Global culture
Our people tell us that our global culture is one of the biggest attractions of a career with Grant…
-
Learning & development
At Grant Thornton we believe learning and development opportunities allow you to perform…
-
Global talent mobility
One of the biggest attractions of a career with Grant Thornton is the opportunity to work on…
-
Diversity
Diversity helps us meet the demands of a changing world. We value the fact that our people come from all…
-
In the community
Many Grant Thornton member firms provide a range of inspirational and generous services to the…
-
Behind the Numbers: People of P&A Grant Thornton
Discover the inspiring stories of the individuals who make up our vibrant community. From seasoned…
-
Fresh Graduates
Fresh Graduates
-
Students
Whether you are starting your career as a graduate or school leaver, P&A Grant Thornton can give you a…
-
Experienced hires
P&A Grant Thornton offers something you can't find anywhere else. This is the opportunity to develop your…
Another year is dawning, and the countdown has begun. As the days go by and we take the first step in faith towards the new year, we hope everyone can reflect and truly say that it was indeed a year of intense growth. Since I am a believer that the new year is neither an end nor a beginning but a going-on, I wish to take everyone back and recall the previous Let’s Talk Transfer Pricing (TP) articles that were published throughout the year so we may welcome 2023 with proper guidance.
To name a few, we started 2022 with our first article entitled “Are your related party transactions at arm's length?” followed by other monthly installments such as “Transfer pricing policies are a must-have", “How FAR are you in transfer pricing documentation?”, “Fundamentals of entity characterization in TPD”, “What’s #TRENDING? Understanding and documenting industry analysis”, and most recently “Understanding transfer pricing methodologies”.
Before 2022 ends, our last Let’s Talk TP article of the year is about the concept of profit level indicator (PLI) in transfer pricing documentation (TPD) as discussed in Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 2-2013 and Revenue Audit Memorandum Order (RAMO) No. 1-2019.
What is PLI?
PLI is the ratio of net profit to an appropriate base (e.g., sales, costs incurred, assets employed). It measures the relationship between the net profits and the appropriate base.
Examples of PLI are return on sales (gross margin or operating margin), return on costs, and return on capital.
Where is PLI used in TPD?
The discussion and selection of an appropriate PLI is presented in the “Application of the transfer pricing method” or “Benchmarking” section of the TPD.
In applying the transfer pricing method, consideration must be given to the choice of PLI. The use of an appropriate PLI ensures better accuracy in the determination of the arm’s length price of a related party transaction.
The Resale Price Method (RPM), Cost Plus Method (CPM) and Transactional Net Margin Method (TNMM) are the transfer pricing methods that use PLI to determine whether the related party transaction involved is carried out at arm’s length.
How do we select an appropriate PLI?
The selection of an appropriate PLI depends on the facts and circumstances of the related party transaction involved. Factors to consider include but are not limited to: (1) characterization of business; (2) availability of comparable data; and (3) the extent to which the PLI is likely to produce a reliable measure of arm’s length profit.
In determining the numerator and denominator of the PLI, taxpayers should bear the following principles in mind: (a) only those items that are directly or indirectly related to the related party transaction involved and are of an operating nature should be considered; and (b) items that are not similar to the independent party transaction being compared should be excluded.
Further, the determination of the denominator used in PLI is done by considering the company's profit drivers and their independence from the denominator that is used. Other factors that need to be considered in selecting the PLI are the type of business and the availability of data.
What are the generally used PLIs?
While PLI differs from case to case depending on the characterization of the business, among others, presented below are the generally used PLIs.
Business characterization is important because by determining the accurate characteristics of the entity’s business, the expected level of price or return by the entity can be known and the selection of reliable comparable can be made.
How is PLI applied?
A benchmarking study or comparable analysis is conducted to find comparable independent transactions or companies to verify the arm's length nature of the related party transactions under evaluation.
a. Search for comparable
In searching for comparable independent transactions or companies, commercial databases are advisable to generate reliable comparable. The data obtained from the commercial database only constitutes candidate comparable. The candidate comparable must undergo manual selection process (i.e., General and Financial Review) mentioned in RAMO No. 1-2019 to be able to produce the list of final comparable.
b. Use of multiple year data
Then, the chosen appropriate PLI of the final comparable is computed. Multiple-year data or PLI (usually 3 years) rather than single-year data improves the reliability of the analysis. The inclusion of numerous years of data makes it easier to pinpoint variables that may have influenced or should have influenced transfer prices, like long-term arrangements and business or product life cycles which may also need to be considered when determining comparability. Further, the use of multiple year data would help neutralize the impact of extreme data points, like abnormally high profits or abnormal losses, while at the same time ensuring that the arm’s length range/ price is representative of the data points identified.
c. Use of interquartile range
In some cases, it will be possible to apply the arm's length principle to arrive at a single figure of PLI that is the most reliable to establish whether the conditions of a transaction are at arm's length. However, because transfer pricing is not an exact science, there will be many occasions when the application of the most appropriate method produces a range of figures all of which are equally reliable. This is often the case in practice where the comparable is extracted from a commercial database. In such cases, if the range includes many observations, statistical tools that account for central tendency to narrow the range (e.g., the interquartile range or other percentiles) might help enhance the analysis's reliability.
d. Benchmarking
The PLI of the tested party or related party transaction involved is compared with the interquartile range of PLIs of the comparable.
If the PLI of the tested party is within the arm’s length range, the related party transaction is carried out at arm’s length basis hence, there would be no adjustment to be made by the tax authority in case of audit.
However, if the PLI of the tested party falls outside the arm's length range, the tested party must be able to present justifiable commercial reasons that the conditions of the related party transaction satisfy the arm's length principle. But if the tested party is unable to establish this fact, the related party transaction is not carried at arm’s length basis hence, the tax authority would make adjustments and determine the point within the arm's length range to which it will adjust the conditions of the related party transaction.
Takeaway
Much like how life is about the choices we make and how the direction of our lives comes down to the choices we take, the use of an appropriate PLI grants taxpayers relief from questioning by tax authorities. Good life choices help us build healthy relationships and reliable PLI ensures better accuracy in the determination of the arm’s length price of a controlled transaction. As we welcome the new year, may we all start doing our best to make decisions that matter, both in life and in choosing the appropriate PLI.
Happy new year and we hope everyone makes the conscious choice of staying tuned in for next month’s Let’s Talk TP article as we walk you through the remaining concepts of transfer pricing.
Let's Talk TP is an offshoot of Let’s Talk Tax, a weekly newspaper column of P&A Grant Thornton that aims to keep the public informed of various developments in taxation. This article is not intended to be a substitute for competent professional advice.
As published in BusinessWorld, dated 27 December 2022